Research & Insights

Why one anti-drone research system appears twice in the literature

A 2022 journal study and an encyclopedia entry by one of its authors describe related research. A subsequent review shows how counting references can overstate the number of independently demonstrated systems.

By UXV Searcher Research Desk, Research and Editorial TeamPublished Primary announcement 9 Feb 20241 min read
LinkedIn

The UXV Searcher Research Desk produced this analysis with AI assistance. The cited publishers are responsible for their original reporting.

Reported

The 2022 publications have a common origin

A February 2022 Sensors paper surveyed drone detection methods and presented the authors’ own software-defined-radio research system. An encyclopedia entry attributed to coauthor Alexandru Martian was added later that month and identifies the related journal work. The two publications should retain separate bibliographic records.[S1] [S2] [S3] [S4]

Reported

What a later review adds

A February 2024 preprint reviewed detection, classification and tracking approaches across commercial counter-drone systems. A literature review can establish which approaches are discussed in print. It does not turn each cited product into an independently observed deployment or make a second account of the same research prototype a new system. A 2020 radar review considering both birds and aircraft illustrates why an application-specific review can overlap with a later general survey.[S1] [S2] [S3] [S4]

UXV Searcher analysis

UXV Searcher analysis

Decide what to count before estimating the size of the evidence base. In this example, publication count, independently demonstrated prototype count and commercial installation count are three different quantities. A literature search can substantiate the first while leaving the other two unresolved.[S1] [S2] [S3] [S4]

Sources

Original reporting is credited to its publisher. The byline covers UXV Searcher's analysis only.

  1. [S1]Sensors original paper, 14 February 2022
    Sensors original paper · 14 Feb 2022
    Cited in “The 2022 publications have a common origin”.
  2. [S2]MDPI Encyclopedia entry and version history
    encyclopedia.pub
    Cited in “The 2022 publications have a common origin”.
  3. [S3]Preprints.org review publication record, February 2024
    Preprints.org review publication record
    Cited in “The 2022 publications have a common origin”.
  4. [S4]Journal of Radars review of bird and UAV recognition, 2020
    Journal of Radars review of bird and UAV recognition
    Cited in “The 2022 publications have a common origin”.

Related in UXV Searcher

Explore the anti-drone market

Compare counter-UAS announcements with the underlying contract, market and supplier records.

Share this analysis

LinkedIn

Need the underlying records or a custom brief? Contact UXV Searcher or see access options.